This can only be interpreted as an invitation to the national security apparatus to continue to lie to the courts. Project Sidewinder reported that the individuals the Chinese government hired to found CITIC had been accused of participating in organized crime in China and Hong Kong. In 2016, Justin Trudeau appointed a career civil servant who was the President of the Canada China Business Council (CCBC) to the Senate of Canada. “Having approved operations that were on their face illegal,” the ruling stated, “the service then collected information which in turn was put before this court in support of warrant applications, without notifying the court of the likely illegality.”. This is the third time in recent years that the Federal Court has ruled that CSIS lied to it. The real objective of the section of the establishment on whose behalf Judge Gleeson speaks is not to “reform” CSIS or even to end its illegal practices. CSIS is Canada's lead agency on national security matters and for conducting national security investigations and security intelligence collection. Factual Reporting: HIGH Country: USA World Press Freedom Rank: USA 45/180 History. The pandemic has 'deepened fissures between authoritarian states and Western liberal democracies,' a declassified CSIS report said. CSIS claimed that in paying informers it was only doing what every other intelligence agency does, and the Ministers of Public Security and Justice, Bill Blair and David Lametti, asserted that “at no time was the safety of Canadians at risk, nor were our rights and freedoms.” As if the government and the premier intelligence agency breaking the law and lying to the courts does not constitute an arrogation of state power and thus implicitly threaten and violate Canadians’ rights. Rendered by Judge Patrick Gleeson, the ruling concerned numerous cases in which CSIS obtained Federal Court warrants authorizing intrusive surveillance by hiding from the court that the information supporting its warrant requests had been obtained illegally. Detailed Report. This is outrageous. Like the Gleeson ruling, “sensitizing” Canadians to a glorified history of CSIS and its predecessor, the RCMP Security Service, is part of the ruling elite’s preparations to suppress any mass movement in opposition to austerity, imperialist aggression, and its prioritizing of profit over human lives amidst the worst pandemic in a century. What is CSIS ? The website discloses donors who have given over $5000. The Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) is at the forefront of Canada's national security system. The CSIS International Security Program (ISP) is a constant source of reliable analysis on the threats and opportunities shaping U.S. security interests at home and abroad. Established over 50 years ago, the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) is a Washington DC based think tank, nonprofit policy research organization dedicated to providing strategic insights and policy solutions to help decision-makers chart a course toward a better world. It has been labeled a “centrist” think tank by U.S. News & World Report. Its ability to do so, despite implementing a massive military spending increase, further integrating Canada into Washington’s military-strategic offensives around the world, slashing tens of billions from health care spending, and spearheading a homicidal back-to-work/back-to-school policy amid the coronavirus pandemic, is entirely bound up with the support it receives from the trade unions and NDP. They also publish well sourced opinion commentary that is factual and minimally biased as well: Hope for the Climate. One of the most important changes made by Bill C-59 was to give almost absolute immunity to CSIS agents who violate Canadian laws in the course of their operations. The auditorium is of modern and sophisticated design, with facilities including built-in sound system, audio and video recording, multiple projectors and large projector screens, and stage lighting. The Trudeau government intends to confront this challenge by continuing to increase the powers of the security forces, while camouflaging its anti-democratic actions, as it has done since coming to power in 2015, with phony “progressive” posturing. Their role is to provide judicial cover for a reactionary service whose main task is to monitor and spy on the Canadian population so as to defend Canadian capitalism and its state. The Liberal election platform promised only to repeal troubling elements of another security law, Bill C-51 — changes that are not due until next fall. Liberalism, political doctrine that takes protecting and enhancing individual freedom to be the central problem of politics. He was first elected as a Liberal Member of Parliament for the Toronto riding of Don Valley in 1968. Instead, he developed a pseudo-legal test that gives judges full discretion to accept the evidence if it is in the “interest of the community [because of] the seriousness or imminence of a threat to the security of Canada.”. CSIS Security Concerns. What are your tasks as an intern and what kind of experiences will you gain? These are the most credible media sources. Canada’s primary foreign surveillance agency, CSE connived with CSIS in the illegal retention and use of metadata that was the object of the Related Data case. Phone: +62 21 386 5532 Rendered by Judge Patrick Gleeson, the … The Liberal government however did reject the takeover of major Canadian construction giant Aecon bid by CCCI, a Chinese SOE, in 2018. Factual Reporting: VERY HIGH Finally, the website offers several blogs covering different topics that is less formal than their research and again minimally biased in presentation. Factual Reporting: VERY HIGH Country: USA World Press Freedom Rank: USA 45/180 History. (D. Van Zandt 6/6/2016) Updated (1/25/2020). He refused to impose any consequences on them for breaking the law and lying to the court. In terms of views on social issues, conservatives oppose gay marriage, abortion and embryonic stem cell research. The Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) is one of the most respected think tanks in Washington. According to press reports, Judge Gleeson’s 151-page decision highlighted seven cases where CSIS acted in this manner. Terms and Conditions Tanah Abang 3 No. Overall, we rate the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) Least Biased based on balanced story selection and minimal editorial bias. Vigneault sought to exonerate himself by saying that when he took office as head of CSIS, in June 2017, he wasn’t properly informed of the controversy surrounding these operations. But C-44 looks to remain untouched. This means that since the Liberals’ legislation came into force on June 21, 2019, the criminal activities revealed by Judge Gleeson are perfectly legal. The case of the illegal terrorist informants involved not only CSIS and government lawyers, but also unnamed top government officials who authorized operations they knew to be illegal. Canada's spy service destroyed a Cold War dossier on Pierre Trudeau in 1989 instead of turning it over to the national archives, The Canadian Press has learned. Our donors make it possible for the Center to develop the strategic insights and bipartisan policy solutions that help decision makers chart a course toward a more peaceful and prosperous world. CSIS is non-partisan. In November, shortly after the Trudeau government announced its appeal of Gleeson’s judgment, it let it be known that it is exploring the possibility of creating a centre to facilitate the declassification of historical Canadian secret service documents. Were such a body to be created, it would be used to project a false image of transparency, and, as indicated by comments from various “security experts,” to glorify the country’s intelligence agencies. Conservatives Seek CSIS Investigation Into Liberal John McCallum’s Disturbing China Interference Remarks News SpencerFernando July 12, 2019 10 “This advice was partisan in nature and encouraged the government of China to take specific actions in order to influence Canada’s democratic process,” says Conservative Deputy Leader Lisa Raitt in letter. CSIS waiting on Liberal reforms before using threat-disruption powers. Liberals on the other hand, are more left-leaning and generally supportive of the right of gay people to get married and women's right to choose to have an abortion, as ruled by the U.S. Supreme Court in Roe v Wade.With regard to the right to bear arms, conservatives support this right as it applies to all US citizens, where… This was an obvious attempt to deflect attention from the government’s cover-up and complicity in CSIS’s ongoing crimes. The reporting is factual and usually sourced. With the blessing of the Justice Department, CSIS persisted in these illegal operations and deliberately concealed them from the court in order to obtain warrants long after the department’s own lawyers had officially determined in January 2017 that they were illegal. The Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) is grateful for the generous support it receives from individuals, foundations, corporations, and governments. Robert Kaplan, former cabinet minister, was CSIS founder, he died of brain cancer (and they say there is no such thing as a just god ?) The Canadian Security and Intelligence Service's use of publicly available geolocation data without a warrant may have broken the law, according to the country's intelligence watchdog. Justin Trudeau’s Liberal government is appealing a May 15 judgment against the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS). Pakarti Centre Building, Jl. Justin Trudeau’s Liberal government is appealing a May 15 judgment against the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS). CSIS’ role is to investigate activities suspected of constituting threats to the security of Canada and to report on these to the Government of Canada. Phone. This legislation expands the repressive powers of the state, particularly those of CSIS and the Communications Security Establishment (CSE). Breadcrumb Trail Links. CSIS is the acronym for Canadian Security Intelligence Service. Detailed Report. Some notable donors are Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, Carnegie Corporation of New York and Charles Koch Foundation. Fair Use Policy Read our profile on United States government and media. In order to hide the reactionary nature of its new legislation, the Trudeau government has touted the creation of so-called review mechanisms, including an intelligence commissioner and the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency. They presented the illegal actions as a minor technical infraction, and glossed over the fact that CSIS and the government had systematically lied to the court. Judge Gleeson’s decision was the result of an investigation ordered by the Federal Court on the basis of suspicions that CSIS and government lawyers had systematically withheld information in violation of their “duty of candour”—in other words, that they had lied. Some in the West believe that China’s political system does not conform to the “liberal democratic model,” whose basic features include electoral democracy and a multi-party system. Established over 50 years ago, the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) is a Washington DC based think tank, nonprofit policy research organization dedicated to providing strategic insights and policy solutions to help decision-makers chart a course toward a better world. Liberals back CSIS in torture lawsuit The Liberal government is continuing the legal fight against compensation for three Canadians tortured overseas — despite previously voting in favour of their cause News Feb 06, 2016 by Tonda MacCharles OurWindsor.Ca Although all details of the seven cases were expunged from the public version of Gleeson’s decision, which was released on July 16, it appears that they all related to efforts by CSIS to infiltrate Islamist terrorist groups in Syria (and perhaps elsewhere in the Middle East) in order to obtain information about Canadians who may have joined their ranks. The Center for a New American Security (CNAS) is a Washington, D.C.-based think tank established in 2007 by co-founders Michèle Flournoy and Kurt M. Campbell which specializes in U.S. national security issues. But the number of cases was clearly higher, since according to the same reports, the current CSIS director, David Vigneault, had personally approved more than 10 operations involving “potentially illegal activities.”. Country: USA CSIS fellow insisting Boko Haram is “increasingly unstable” One of the starkest examples, one that FAIR noted at the time , was a New York Times article ( 8/20/15 ) last year, warning about the US “lagging behind” Russia in the Arctic Ocean, that was based almost entirely on a CSIS report warning of “Russia’s strategic reach” near the north pole. The CSIS starting tracking deaths in 1994, claiming that it selected that start date because it didn't have enough reliable data to track before 1994. The think tank is known for inviting well-known foreign policy and public service officials from the U.S. Congress and the executive branch including those affiliated with either the Democratic or the Republican Party as well as foreign officials of varying political backgrounds. This explains the judge’s sympathy for the spies and their lawyers, whom he criticized above all for “breaking the bond of trust between the Court and CSIS and its lawyers.” The anti-democratic implications of the gross violation of the rights of Canadian citizens by CSIS are not worthy of mention in the judgment, other than a reference or two, rhetorically, to the importance of the “rule of law.”, In the end, the judgment, which was released to the media by the Federal Court despite the secrecy that normally surrounds national security matters, was a public relations ploy by the Canadian state. Canada's Liberal government is blind to China's interference and elite capture, critics say. CSIS also highlighted the threat of Canadian extremism directed at India. Funding, View mediabiasfactcheck’s profile on Facebook, The Latest Fact Checks curated by Media Bias Fact Check 12/29/2020, Daily Source Bias Check: Salem Radio Network News, The Latest Fact Checks curated by Media Bias Fact Check 12/28/2020, Daily Source Bias Check: Technocracy News, Center for Strategic and International Studies, Growing number of House Republicans warm to proxy voting, The Latest Fact Checks curated by Media Bias Fact Check 12/27/2020, The Latest Fact Checks curated by Media Bias Fact Check 12/26/2020, The Latest Fact Checks curated by Media Bias Fact Check 12/25/2020, The Latest Fact Checks curated by Media Bias Fact Check 12/24/2020. Desmarais is the son–in–law of Jean Chrétien. Connect with Us 1616 Rhode Island Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20036 [email protected] @CSISDefense360 CSIS publishes in-depth reports that are factual and low biased such as this Civil Society in the North Caucasus. A factual search reveals they have never failed a fact check. All this is now compounded with the Liberal government’s attempt to overturn Gleeson’s ruling. “The circumstances,” Gleeson continued in his judgment, “raise fundamental questions relating to respect for the rule of law, the oversight of security intelligence activities and the actions of individual decision-makers.”. However, as the WSWS explained in its analysis of Bill C-59, these mechanisms, like the Federal Court, “are nothing more than a fig leaf, aimed at providing the intelligence agencies with a legal-constitutional cover.” They have no binding power over CSIS and they conduct their “watch-dog” oversight activities in complete secrecy, well beyond the eye of Parliament, let alone public scrutiny. International Committee of the Fourth International, Canadian spy agency concealed mass data intelligence-bank from courts, Canada: New federal law expands national security agencies’ repressive powers, Canada’s military launched operation to “shape” opinion amid pandemic, NSA spying and the 2013 revelations of Edward Snowden. Just before the 2019 election, which saw Trudeau reelected as leader of a minority government, the then Liberal-controlled Parliament passed Bill C-59, an Act on Matters of National Security. CSIS director Richard Fadden waits to testify at the Commons public safety committee on Parliament Hill in July. In press releases issued on July 16, the Trudeau government and CSIS indicated that they would accept Judge Gleeson’s decision, while seeking to minimize and justify what happened. Enter your email address to subscribe to MBFC and receive notifications of new posts by email. Rather, its goal is to ensure that CSIS works even more closely with the Federal Court to foster the “democratic” image of the national security apparatus among Canadians, so the intelligence agency has the greatest latitude in carrying out its function as a key instrument to surveil and repress social opposition to the government, the capitalist elite, and its agenda among the population in general, and especially the working class. Judge Gleeson wrote that their predecessor, the Security Intelligence Review Committee, had been well aware of CSIS’s illegal activities for several years, but had neither succeeded in stopping them nor seen fit to reveal them to the public. These sources have minimal bias and use very few loaded words (wording that attempts to influence an audience by using appeal to emotion or stereotypes). A Liberal Member of Parliament has acknowledged meeting an Iranian businessman accused of helping Tehran circumvent international sanctions, … 23-27, Jakarta 10160, Indonesia. Judge Gleeson’s sole “corrective” was to recommend the government order a thorough investigation of CSIS’s adherence to and attitude toward its “duty of candour.” The desired review will never take place, as evidenced by the federal government’s decision to appeal the judgment rather than order a review of CSIS’s adherence to the law. However, senior CSIS officials decided it wouldn’t be appropriate to pursue more serious so-called “threat-reduction activities” that require a judge’s sign-off, while the Liberal government is actively considering how it will amend the law, a source with direct knowledge of … Both are members of the Concord Coalition, a non-profit co-founded by Peterson. Liberals typically believe that government is necessary to protect individuals from being harmed by others, but they also recognize that government itself can pose a threat to liberty. News; Canadian Politics; New anti-terrorism bill abandons Liberal call for real-time parliamentary 'oversight' into CSIS. By Alex Boutilier Ottawa Bureau Reporter Tonda MacCharles Ottawa Bureau reporter. The federal government is reviewing its use of so-called lie detector tests in security screenings as a new report called out the controversial practice. World Press Freedom Rank: USA 45/180. The “security experts” quoted in the media criticized Canada for lagging behind its allies in disclosing historic national security and intelligence files, while suggesting that a declassification centre would strengthen public support for CSIS and other arms of the state security apparatus by raising “Canadians’ awareness of the practice, importance and challenges of national security.”. CSIS is proud to own its own conference auditorium in its current premises, which is large enough to host an audience of 250 people. Their flagship publication is the Washington Quarterly. See all Least Biased sources. Nor did Judge Gleeson rule that any evidence that the state had obtained illegally should be declared inadmissible in any future court cases. The timidity of Justice Gleeson’s judgment is not surprising. November 5, 2012. In the 2016 Related Data case, the Federal Court concluded that it had unknowingly issued warrants on the basis of information obtained illegally from an extensive metadata collection and retention program. CSIS is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization that is funded through donations. Chrétien himself sat on the board of a Power Corp subsidiary before his election as Liberal leader. Bill C-59 was promoted as a democratic reform of the law the Harper government passed in 2015, with Liberal support, that in the name of “fighting terrorism” gave vast new powers to Canada’s national security apparatus. The government appeal is all the more remarkable in that Judge Gleeson did little more than issue a public reprimand to CSIS and their government overseers. Accordingly, Judge Gleeson issued several warnings to CSIS that such behaviour would “undermine public confidence in the [Canadian Security Intelligence] Service” as a “vital national institution.”. However, Bill C-59 retains the fundamental provisions of Harper’s law—whose powers were so sweeping that even the Globe and Mail termed it a “police state” bill—while adding further anti-democratic measures. CSIS collects, analyzes intelligence, advises the Government of Canada on issues and activities that may threaten the security of Canada and its citizens. One, an Inspector General whose sole job was to review CSIS activities would be put in place and report to the Solicitor General, and two, the Security Intelligence Review Committee (SIRC), a panel that reported to Parliament. Sam Nunn and Donald B. Marron both have known ties to Peter G. Peterson. We also rate them Very High for factual reporting due to exceptional sourcing of information and a clean fact check record. OTTAWA — The former director of Canada’s spy agency says recent Conservative and Liberal governments have “failed abominably” on foreign policy work with China. The intern works in the European department at CSIS and participates in the daily activities, such as organising events, conducting research, participating at meetings and following other events organised by other think-tanks. Wed., April 12, … And notwithstanding the 1997 Sidewinder report, the Liberal government is seemingly back at it with their Chinese overlords. By paying members of these groups to spy on its behalf, CSIS violated—and knew it was violating—Anti-Terrorism Act prohibitions on the financing of terrorist activities. This included senior personnel within the Department of Justice and the Privy Council Office, which directly advises the Prime Minister and oversees the implementation of his decisions. The handful of Federal Court judges appointed to hear national security cases behind closed doors are fully integrated into Canada’s security apparatus. In general, this is a highly factual low biased source of information. Therefore, they have determined that the Chinese political system is non-democratic: totalitarian, despotic, or authoritarian. As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to rage across Canada, exacerbating social inequalities and class tensions, there is great concern in ruling circles that opposition to its right-wing policies is taking increasingly militant forms. Briefly interrupted after they were deemed illegal, the operations were resumed with the sanction of the department of justice in March 2017.