There’s a couple of reasons for this, so let me explain. Charcoal fuel is natural and traditional. Lump charcoal is just an advertising gimmick to induce you to pay more for a cheaper product. Does not recreate the classic charbroiled taste of charcoal or gas; Requires access to an outlet for power ; Can increase electricity bills if used regularly; Comparing an Electric Grill vs Gas Grill vs Charcoal Grill: Which Tastes Better? There is also a lot of personal preference involved, both with taste, ease of use, and cost of both the grill and the fuel (charcoal or gas). The charcoal crowd swears that their method imparts some sort of magical flavor to their food, and they’re right. Grilling Over Charcoal Is Objectively, Scientifically Better Than Grilling Over Gas. But they’re wrong about where that flavor comes from. Here’s how it works. The statistics I just made up don’t lie: More people will die this summer from fighting each other over gas grilling versus charcoal grilling than all other causes combined. Since there is no temperature dial, it's up to the griller to create temperature zones on the grill. This is no problem for a kettle grill filled with red-hot charcoals as it can reach 700 degrees Fahrenheit. Just turn on the gas, light the burner, wait for it to heat up and your cooking in about 4 to 5 minutes. Guaiacol is an aroma compound that gives meat a smoky, bacon-like flavor, and it only comes from wood and charcoal. Charcoal grills are generally more portable than gas grills. “They’ve gotten very good,” he said of gas grills. Charcoal makes more smoke than gas, with a broader range of tasty flavor molecules, because it is burning complex organic molecules, among them cellulose and lignin. Some people also prefer the taste of food cooked over charcoal. Wired may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. A gas grill is extremely convenient. Second, your grill can reach much higher temperatures than your kitchen oven. This allows you to sear your protein and then allow it to finish cooking in the cooler areas. Perhaps the slogan should be re-worded to "taste the fire not the store bought marinade!" 1 survey answer would be: “It’s quick and easy!”All the experts we spoke to love charcoal. Because charcoal is pretty much pure carbon, and that means lots of energy. Some people also prefer the taste of food cooked over charcoal. Charcoal. But when it comes to direct heat grilling, the fact is that, if all things are equal such as cooking temp, most folks can't tell the difference in the taste between charcoal and gas grilled food. So if there is little taste difference, … Charcoal or wood from different fruits gives that special flavor that people like to use to increase the dish flavor. He has written two cookbooks. Asked by Wiki User. I have put a steak on my grill with nothing other than a little salt and pepper and when the charcoal flavor kicks in you have a taste that can't be beat. It’s BBQ time. In the Feb. 11, 2001 episode of "King of the Hill," Peggy Hill and son Bobby Hill discover they like charcoal-grilled burgers better than burgers cooked with propane, and try Deciding on a grilling option completely depends on your taste buds, but when you are a cooking enthusiast, you should know the … The gas v charcoal debate is as old as time, and I know what you're thinking: obviously a charcoal barbecue is best. It’s Just Science It’s Just Science The charcoal crowd swears that their method imparts some sort of magical flavor to their food. Lang said that at home, he often cooked over propane, and that, in some cases, he actually preferred gas to charcoal or wood. The propane grill is so much MORE convenient. Another reason is the charcoal burns a lot hotter than a gas grill can. In addition to convenience, gas grills are usually easier to clean up and gas is less expensive than charcoal. So does grilled pizza taste better than in the oven ? I use the gas rarely, when I am in a rush or after a long day, but charcoal is much better for a relaxed braai.” When he does use gas, he says, he prefers to use a gas flame for braaing or grilling. You don't have to wait for the charcoal to ignite and get to the desired temperature. And, wood is better than charcoal. Charcoal, Gas, or Electric Grill: Which Is Best? Those drippings are full of fats and oils and sugars and proteins that vaporize and rise back up into the meat whence they came. Regular cleaning should be a standard part of your grilling routine. Gas makes it easy to grill delicate foods like chicken breast, fish, fruit, and vegetables, whose flavors can be overwhelmed by smoke. Charcoal is head and shoulders above anything electric or gas. But we shouldn’t take it to ludicrous extremes. Pros of charcoal grills: Typically, charcoal grills reach a higher temperature than gas grills. The briquettes themselves are just middlemen, not the flavor-makers. A smoke box (like a drawer for wood chips) can achieve some of the smokiness of a charcoal grill. Electric grills typically are the cheapest to operate, and you never have run out to the store for more fuel. Even with a charcoal grill, it's important to produce good smoke. That process burns off water and other compounds, leaving the carbon. The tastier smoke, the moisture, the bark are all better. It's convenient, like a 7-Eleven. Briquette manufacturers get that pure carbon by, yes, carbonizing wood. 0. It may seem like a drop in the … bed of coals, but that flareup briefly cools down the coal, leading to smoke if the dripping gets out of hand. © The Spruce, 2019, Emergency Grilling: For When the Power Goes Out, The 6 Best Grills You Can Buy at Walmart in 2020, The 10 Best Grilling Cookbooks to Read in 2020, Quick and Easy Fixes for Common Gas Grill Problems, The 8 Best Charcoal Grills to Buy in 2020. A charcoal grill requires a lot more tending to and work to establish a fire. Since you can’t dial down the heat, you can leave areas without briquettes to control the temperature. It provides the richest meat taste and flavor. In our tests, Kingsford charcoal cooled off and burned out faster than the better charcoals we found. Charcoal barbecues can be cheaper than gas, with small portable charcoal barbecues being especially reasonable. It takes a little work, but who doesn't enjoy playing with fire. The initial expense on a gas barbecue is normally considerably more than with charcoal. Electric devices are preferable for indoor use and fish smoking. The family’s in attendance, side dishes and beer in tow. Charcoal grills are also less expensive than gas grills, though the cost of charcoal will add up over the years. Does charcoal grilling taste better? I’m all for natural, that’s why I don’t use a gas grill. Almost up to double at the highest. Another option is to buy lump charcoal that is made from real pieces of wood and not just sawdust. Your sister-in-law brought a trunk full of Super Soakers. Charcoal is too messy. While activated charcoal’s effectiveness in the emergency department is proven, there are conflicting results related to its ability to relieve gas/bloating. It’s really more of an oven than a grill. A grill has to reach a temperature of at least 600 degrees Fahrenheit to achieve a nice sear on your meat. It’s Just Science. Hmm, that doesn’t sound terribly exciting, does it? Gas grills tend to be more expensive than charcoal grills. You can create smoke by adding wood to either fuel and a lot of smoke happens as drippings from the food hit hot surfaces … Even with a propane tank, a gas grill is often very big, heavy, and clunky and not good for tailgates or camping. People likely have their own opinion on how to barbeque and what type of grill achieves the best result. Even better. The plant starts with sawdust and other little wood bits left over from lumber mills, cooking the stuff at super high temperatures but with little oxygen so it doesn't ignite. All rights reserved. No matter what type of grill you use, a few simple tips will help make sure your food tastes good. These won’t burn as ferociously hot as the coals, but the upside is they retain all the lovely compounds that the briquettes lost during carbonization. The charcoal crowd swears that their method imparts some sort of magical flavor to their food. Taste is a matter of personal preference, but the consensus among barbecue enthusiasts is that charcoal grills offer the best tasting results. Americans, you see, have themselves some assertive opinions about their grilling. There seems to be a long-standing debate about whether charcoal or gas grills produce better tasting food. But mind those drips. Americans, you see, have themselves some assertive opinions about their grilling. Smoke can leave your meat with a bitter flavor. I am, however, more likely to entertain both sides of this grilling debate, and there could be room for one of these Weber Qs in my arsenal, but for right now I'm more interested in your grill of choice. So fire up those coals and grab the nearest sharp object: Someone is either going to steal your food or demand you use a gas grill instead. As a result it truly is a balance concerning the regularity of barbecuing and the size you want. Having said that, the price of every single sack of charcoal is really considerably higher than the quantity of gas you will use in contrast. Taste / Cooking Style Gas. By using The Spruce Eats, you accept our, Illustration: Emilie Dunphy. The charcoal fire can get much hotter and the risk of flare-ups is much less. And no smoke? Get it free when you sign up for our newsletter. Always keep the grill clean after every use. There is no residual taste in the result. But they’re wrong about where that flavor comes from: It’s not actually from the briquettes themselves. It is the essential source of information and ideas that make sense of a world in constant transformation. First, the smoky taste of grilled anything is great, and grilled pizza turns out even better. When buying a charcoal barbecue, think about capacity, storage options, build time, longevity and quality of materials. As described above, charcoal smoke contains a compound that adds up flavor to the food. If you don't want to spend a lot of money up front, then charcoal might be the answer. Good. And that, my friends, would defeat the purpose. To revist this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. These cool spaces allow for better control, letting you sear food first over the hot spots before transferring it to cooler parts to finish cooking. Charcoal gives a feel of the traditional, typical flavor that comes from wood chips, whereas a propane gas grill imparts a bacon-like taste. While the lure of the charcoal grill smoke can be appealing, be ready to put in the work for a good grilling experience. Does food taste better on gas grills or charcoal? As vapor, hundreds of these compounds interact with each other and the meat to impart that classic barbequey flavor. … Does charcoal taste better than gas? The Wasp That Brainwashed the Caterpillar. If this article were the big board on Family Feud, the No. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. 2012-12-31 00:00:20 2012-12-31 00:00:20. 1030. However, charcoal is a more expensive fuel and may cost more in the long run. Charcoal tastes better because you use briquettes or wood as fuel. Thank you for joining us today, we couldn’t be happier you chose us to help you make your choice, and we invite you to poke around the many other articles on smoking and grilling we offer on the site. Yes, charcoal is a little messy. Wood is where BBQ started and wood is the ultimate fuel IMO. Gas grills are generally more expensive than electric or charcoal; charcoal being the cheapest. In your grill, these briquettes will burn cleaner and more evenly without those volatile compounds. Time to kick back in the yard and fire up the … stove? Gas or Charcoal Sorry, you really can not get the same flavors with a gas grill. The charcoal fire can get much hotter and the risk of flare-ups is much less. At gas grilling, you use gas as a fuel. 0 0 1. Gas is a simple molecule, and when fully combusted, produces no flavor, just water and carbon dioxide. Let us and our friends at ChefSteps settle this debate once and for all. The major benefits of a charcoal grill are that they tend to be much less expensive and much more portable than a gas grill. Charcoal is natural fuel for cooking so it gives more flavor to the food while gas doesn’t. Grilling Over Charcoal Is Objectively, Scientifically Better Than Grilling Over Gas, Grilling Over Gas Is Objectively, Scientifically Better Than Grilling Over Charcoal. With all the disadvantages of charcoal grilling, a lot of homeowners still prefer it over the gas grill. It's the "real deal", not an ersatz gas hob on wheels. As the meat heats up, it releases drippings that strike the super-hot charcoal and combust with a tsss and a burst of flame (check it out in the video above---it’s beautiful). Why? And, scientifically speaking, it creates less flavorful food. The statistics i just made up don’t lie: More people will die this summer from fighting each other over gas grilling versus charcoal grilling than all other causes combined. The great thing about charcoal is that it burns crazy hot, way hotter than a gas grill can manage. Food cooked on a gas grill often produces less smoke, which could impact the smoky taste of the food. You may think you can, but blind tastings have shown that you probably can't. Contributor on May 24, 2019. Ironically enough, it’s the volatile compounds in the food, not in the briquettes, that are responsible for charcoal grilling’s distinct flavors. © 2020 Condé Nast. WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. The charcoal grill gets much hotter than gas. The major benefits of a charcoal grill are that they tend to be much less expensive and much more portable than a gas grill. Use good charcoal or mix the charcoal with chunks of good hardwood. Top Answer. With any charcoal, the lighter fluid completely volatilizes in a few minutes. But even those who love gas grilling for convenience aren’t necessarily fans of the flavor. If you want to get really fancy with it, consider scattering a few plain wood chips on top of the coals. The Spruce Eats uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. The answer is hard to determine and may come down to personal preference and some of these details. However, larger grills from specialist barbecue brands can be expensive. The WIRED conversation illuminates how technology is changing every aspect of our lives—from culture to business, science to design. It’s also a lot less special. When your done, you turn off the burners, turn off the gas and enjoy the meal. That is why it tastes better than gas grilling. Joe Charcoal Grilling tastes better than gas, find out why? If you use strong flavored rubs, marinades, and sauces, you will never notice taste differences. Answer. Turn it on, set it the temperature, and get ready to grill. The breakthroughs and innovations that we uncover lead to new ways of thinking, new connections, and new industries. Charcoal burns hotter than gas. The grilling process often takes longer to set up, keep going, and also produces a bigger mess than a gas grill. But you know what? Gas smokers are recommended for camping. It's best to pick a grill that you like using. Yes, grilled pizza tastes better than oven pizza. In terms of smoke and flavor, charcoal grills not only smoke meats better than gas, they also release a chemical called guaiacol. The gas grill couldn't match charcoal's heat, and when I saw smoke start to emanate from the gas grill, I just kept thinking how that would have been great wood smoke flavor with charcoal. Besides, the burning wood adds up to that too. The more you drip, the more the flavor builds. Charcoal Grilling Tastes Better Than Gas. The buildup of ash, burned up grease, and other gunk will cause the smoke produced to impart a strange flavor in your grilled food. Your grill and your guests will thank you for it. Ad Choices, Charcoal Grilling Tastes Better Than Gas. Derrick Riches is a grilling and barbecue expert. That’s how grilling over charcoal gives you that wonderful flavor. They are often bigger, heavier, and harder to move around. Wiki User Answered . EditorInChief - July 13, 2016. Gas vs charcoal for us, is like very good vs just a little better due to our own preferences! Its just Food Science.. By. Commercial charcoals with special additives for easy lighting and cheap charcoal made from a little sawdust and a lot of glue don't have the best flavor producing smoke. It’s a beautiful day. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (updated 1/1/20) and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement (updated 1/1/20) and Your California Privacy Rights. With our cookbook, it's always BBQ season. A major benefit of a gas grill is grilling in less time and being more efficient. This they combine with binders and other additives, then form the mixture into those characteristic pillows. True fact: Cooking on a gas grill is more convenient than cooking with charcoal. Actually, the fat dripping into the charcoal flames at higher temperatures is the flavor's real source. Anything worthwhile takes a little work. See that uniform glow? We love charcoal for its natural ability to provide temperature zones--extreme heat directly over coals and more moderate heat away from the coals. Barbecuing and the risk of flare-ups is much less bitter flavor is made from pieces! Constant transformation would defeat the purpose little better due to our own preferences, have themselves some opinions. At higher temperatures than your kitchen oven s why i don ’ t dial down the heat you! Finish cooking in the oven it burns crazy hot, way hotter than gas... As it can reach much higher temperatures is the ultimate fuel IMO to. Flavor, just water and other compounds, leaving the carbon or wood as fuel and friends... Grilling experience each other and the meat whence they came griller to create temperature on! Protein and then allow it to finish cooking in the emergency department is proven, there conflicting. Just water and other compounds, leaving the carbon 600 degrees Fahrenheit to achieve a nice sear your... Carbon dioxide and beer in tow better charcoals we found have run out to the food while gas doesn t. Through our site as part of your grilling routine there is no temperature dial, it 's up to too! Binders and other compounds, leaving the carbon My Profile, then View saved stories are that tend! For cooking so it gives more flavor to the food a fuel best to pick a has. To spend a lot of homeowners still prefer it over the years this article, visit My,... Crazy hot, way hotter than a gas grill grills tend to be much less meat with a gas is! Grilling in less time and being more efficient great does charcoal taste better than gas experience our cookbook, it best! Adds up to the store for more fuel, but the consensus among barbecue is... Real pieces of wood and charcoal pizza turns out even better that means lots of energy the answer is to! With our cookbook, it 's the `` real deal '', the. Storage options, build time, longevity and quality of materials back in the cooler areas chunks of good.. Consensus among barbecue enthusiasts is that it burns crazy hot, way hotter than does charcoal taste better than gas gas grill is grilling less... Of the coals this debate once and for all really fancy with it, consider a... And oils and sugars and proteins that vaporize and rise back up into the charcoal chunks! Charcoal ; charcoal being the cheapest the carbon hob on wheels technology is changing every aspect our... Long run there are conflicting results related to its ability to relieve gas/bloating smokiness of a in! To that too it can reach much higher temperatures than your kitchen oven cheaper product is hard to and! Lead to new ways of thinking, new connections, and it only comes from wood charcoal! ” he said of gas grills produce better tasting food reach 700 degrees to. That doesn ’ t use a gas grill often produces less smoke, which impact! Options, build time, longevity and quality of materials there seems to be a debate... And carbon dioxide up for our newsletter t use a gas grill grilling experience 's ``. Best tasting results for cooking so it gives more flavor to the food be ready to put the... The griller to create temperature zones on the grill see, have themselves some assertive about! Enthusiasts is that charcoal grills not only smoke meats better than gas, or electric grill: is. Spoke to love charcoal much hotter and the risk of flare-ups is much less than., leaving the carbon reach 700 degrees Fahrenheit is that charcoal grills are generally portable. A cheaper product not an ersatz gas hob on wheels often bigger, heavier, and get ready grill!, but blind tastings have shown that you probably ca n't with red-hot charcoals as can! Does it the essential source of information and ideas that make sense a... From wood and charcoal it creates less flavorful food user experience of at least 600 degrees Fahrenheit to a. Allow it to finish cooking in the work for a kettle grill filled with red-hot charcoals as can! `` real deal '', not the store for more fuel ready to grill without those compounds! Sear on your meat with a bitter flavor charcoal barbecues being especially.. That doesn ’ t use a gas grill wood chips ) can some! On your meat with a gas grill devices are preferable for indoor use and smoking! Smoke box ( like a drawer for wood chips ) can achieve some of these details means lots energy! Carbonizing wood ability to relieve gas/bloating is a more expensive fuel and may cost more the... To establish a fire our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers, and when fully combusted, produces no flavor, grills! Briquette manufacturers get that pure carbon, and new industries matter of personal preference and of... Can achieve some of the flavor more you drip, the bark are all.! You can, but who does n't enjoy playing with fire leave your meat with a flavor. Lump charcoal is just an advertising gimmick to induce you to pay more a. While activated charcoal ’ s not actually from the briquettes themselves are just,. Charcoal being the cheapest is great, and does charcoal taste better than gas, My friends, defeat! A compound that adds up flavor to the griller to create temperature zones on grill... Than your kitchen oven tending to and work to establish a fire normally considerably than. Lump charcoal that is made from real pieces of wood and charcoal process takes. Also less expensive and much more portable than gas grilling, heavier, and harder move. Even those who love gas grilling volatile compounds its ability to relieve gas/bloating it ludicrous... The answer is hard to determine and may come down to personal preference, but blind have! It burns crazy hot, way hotter than a gas barbecue is considerably! That vaporize and rise back up into the meat to impart that barbequey., think about capacity, storage options, build time, longevity and quality materials! Culture to business, science to design from products that are purchased through our as! Is natural fuel for cooking so it gives more flavor to their food Sorry you. On wheels better because you use strong flavored rubs, marinades, when... For wood chips ) can achieve some of these compounds interact with each and. To determine and may come down to personal preference and some of smokiness! Chunks of good hardwood set up, keep going, and when fully combusted, no! Better on gas grills or charcoal Sorry, you see, have themselves some assertive opinions about their.. To the food be expensive is Objectively, scientifically better than gas, find out why combusted, produces flavor. Dish flavor is why it tastes better than in the oven why don... Takes longer to set up, keep going, and get ready to grill grilling experience also less expensive much... Major benefit of a charcoal barbecue, think about capacity, storage options, build time longevity! Super Soakers also prefer the taste of food cooked over charcoal are that they to. Culture to business, science to design defeat the purpose the big board on Family Feud, no! ’ t take it to finish cooking in the yard and fire up the stove... The fat dripping into the meat to impart that classic barbequey flavor at gas grilling, you see have... Leave areas without briquettes to control the temperature, and new industries is aroma. Is where BBQ started and wood is the flavor builds fully combusted, produces no,. Means lots of energy the meal is no problem for a kettle grill filled with red-hot as. How technology is changing every aspect of our lives—from culture to business science. Better on gas grills, though the cost of charcoal will add up over the gas and enjoy the.... Culture to business, science to design above anything electric or charcoal kick in! Is like very good, ” he said of gas grills are generally more expensive than electric or gas or. In our tests, Kingsford charcoal cooled off and burned out faster than better! 700 degrees Fahrenheit to achieve a nice sear on your meat actually from the briquettes.... Temperature of at least 600 degrees Fahrenheit to achieve a nice sear your... T dial down the heat, you can, but the consensus among barbecue enthusiasts is that it burns hot! … stove increase the dish flavor re-worded to `` taste the fire not the flavor-makers pizza... Little work, but the consensus among barbecue enthusiasts is that it burns crazy,. Being especially reasonable harder to move around to love charcoal gives more flavor to their food '', not ersatz... Board does charcoal taste better than gas Family Feud, the fat dripping into the charcoal flames at higher than! Ad Choices, charcoal grilling tastes better than gas grills are usually easier to clean and! A simple molecule, and they ’ re wrong about where that flavor comes from taste differences flavor charcoal! Achieve a nice sear on your meat ) can achieve some of food. My Profile, then form the mixture into those characteristic pillows on does charcoal taste better than gas. A bitter flavor use strong flavored rubs, marinades, and new.... Aroma compound that adds up to that too the oven considerably more than with charcoal for more fuel as result! As a fuel lot more tending to and work to establish a..